The Mas brothers and Terra plan about 1,215 apartments and about 1,800 parking spaces on an empty 8.4-acre lot at 650 NW 8th St. in Overtown. That is more parking spaces than homes. Florida YIMBY reported the plan after the city's design board reviewed it in 2024.

This week, Alicia Pederson, who writes as Courtyard Urbanist, posted a different plan for the same land: about 944 homes in small buildings around shared gardens, with about 90 parking spots in her concept.

The site

The land covers two full blocks between NW 6th and 7th Avenues and NW 6th and 8th Streets, about a block north of the Miami River, Miami Today reported.

A company tied to Jorge Mas put the site together in 2016 as a possible Inter Miami stadium site. No stadium was built there. The Real Deal reported that the team later planned the stadium on the former Melreese golf course, just east of Miami International Airport.

The Overtown development plan

The applicants are the Mas brothers' 0101 Miami Properties and 8th Street Connections Holdings, an affiliate of Terra. Arquitectonica designed the buildings.

The plan shows three 12-story apartment buildings, a three-story building and a nine-story garage lined with apartments. Homes would run from studios to three bedrooms.

Unit counts differ slightly in the city's file. An applicant letter listed 1,215 apartments and 1,831 parking spaces, Florida YIMBY reported. May 6 drawings listed 1,219 apartments and 1,798 parking spaces, Pederson wrote, citing the city filing. Miami Today later reported about 1,219 homes and parking for 1,800 vehicles.

The developers say the project mixes market-rate, workforce and affordable homes. A lawyer for the team told the board the project doubles the open space the city requires, Miami Today reported.

The city's Urban Development Review Board recommended approval 4-0 on May 15, 2024, Florida YIMBY reported.

The courtyard plan

Pederson's concept has 51 smaller buildings, mostly four to six stories, around five shared gardens and a public square. She counts about 944 homes. Her public workbook counts 93 possible parking spots: 59 at the curb and 34 in small garages. She calls that number a concept, not a final count, and says parking access, engineering and approvals would still need work.

The tradeoff

Compared with the 1,219-home drawings, her plan has about 275 fewer homes, or about 23% fewer. It also has about 95% less parking. That is the same debate Miami has over parking rules for new buildings.

The backstory

Overtown was once called the "Harlem of the South." In the 1960s, I-95 and I-395 were built through its center. An NYU law journal article, citing historian Raymond Mohl, says the interchange took the homes of about 10,000 people, and that by 1968 only about 8,000 of about 40,000 residents were left.

Pederson argues a neighborhood of small buildings would fit that history better than towers and a garage.

What's next

Work on the first phase, about 537 apartments, was expected to start in 2025. As of Nov. 13, no new-building permit was listed for 650 NW 8th St.

Buying or selling in Overtown? The Miami Lookout is founded by Joe Biscaha, a Miami real estate advisor with Compass.