The plan to rebuild the shuttered Miami Seaquarium hit a wall Tuesday.
A County Commission committee refused to send the new 99-year lease forward and voted 3-1 to put it off, WLRN reported. The panel set no new date. The lease is with Resilient Aquarium LLC, an affiliate of developer David Martin's Terra, according to the county's legislative file.
The 249-page lease went public Monday night, less than a day before the meeting. "Why are we getting this at the eleventh hour?" Commissioner Marleine Bastien asked, the Miami Herald reported.
Who stood where
Commissioner Raquel Regalado, whose district includes Virginia Key, sponsored the lease and voted against the delay. She asked colleagues to send it to the full commission without a recommendation so talks could keep going.
Bastien and Commissioner Micky Steinberg pushed back on fast-tracking it. The lease asks the county to skip four weeks of public notice and two independent appraisals it normally requires for county land worth more than $5 million.
Committee Chair René García backed the project but said a motion to approve would not pass. "This is what happens when you wait till the last hour," he told the county administration, Florida Politics reported.
Why the clock matters
The Seaquarium closed to visitors in October 2025, months after its last operator, MS Leisure, filed for bankruptcy. That same month, a bankruptcy court approved selling the old lease to Terra's affiliate for $22.5 million, pending county approval. Commissioners approved the handoff in December 2025 and told the mayor's office to negotiate new terms.
Terra lobbyist Brian May warned that delaying the vote put the deal in "complete and utter jeopardy." Attorney Gene Stearns said the creditors who have been paying the property's bills have run out of money.
García said he would ask Commission Chair Anthony Rodriguez to consider bringing the lease straight to the full board, possibly at a special December meeting. Commissioners pick a new chair on Nov. 17.
What the lease would do
Terra would invest at least $100 million, plus at least $10 million in free public amenities. Plans call for a new aquarium with no marine mammals, a restored Buckminster Fuller dome, the reused Flipper House, a public baywalk, a kayak launch and a marina.
The county would collect at least $1.1 million a year in rent once the project opens, or 3% of land-side revenue and 5% of marina revenue if that is higher. All of it would go to a county parks fund.
The marina is the biggest fight. Environmental groups worry a 295-slip marina could hurt manatees and seagrass in the shallow bay. Terra's team says the marina is needed to pay for the rest of the project, and its plans include a "living edge" seawall.
What's next
- Tuesday, Nov. 17: The County Commission's last scheduled meeting of 2026. A court hearing is also set that day on the county's motion to dismiss a lawsuit seeking a public vote on the project.
- Thursday, Nov. 19: The commission meets on land-use changes for the 38-acre site.
- Wednesday, Dec. 30: Terra's deadline in bankruptcy court, according to its lobbyist.
The Seaquarium lease is separate from the City of Miami's Rickenbacker Marina lease, which city voters rejected on Nov. 3.





