Miami Beach may take the state to court to keep two Art Deco-era oceanfront hotels standing.
On Wednesday, Nov. 18, commissioners will vote on a resolution from Vice Mayor Alex Fernandez that would approve a lawsuit against the Resiliency and Safe Structures Act. The Nov. 18 agenda says the suit is meant to save "the Savoy, the Arlington, and other contributing and architecturally significant" buildings from demolition. It would also let the city attorney hire outside lawyers who specialize in this kind of case, with a budget change later if needed.
What the state law does
The law, Section 553.8991 of the Florida Statutes, covers buildings on land that sits at least partly seaward of the state's coastal construction control line. It applies when a building does not meet current flood-elevation rules, has been declared unsafe, or has been ordered torn down.
For those buildings, a city may not block a demolition for any reason other than public safety. It also cannot require a replacement building to copy the old one, keep any of its parts, or be smaller than zoning allows.
Some buildings are exempt. They include single-family homes, buildings listed one by one on the National Register of Historic Places, and contributing buildings in historic districts that joined the National Register before Jan. 1, 2000.
Why the Savoy and the Arlington
The Savoy was built in 1937 and the Arlington in 1941, according to the resolution. Both are contributing buildings in the city's Ocean Beach Local Historic District, created in 1996. The resolution says many buildings the state law still covers are on the National Register or are contributing buildings in the city's local historic districts.
The resolution does not name the owner or describe the new project. City permit records show a Live Local Act pre-application meeting for 425 to 455 Ocean Drive, filed in April, and a traffic study filed Oct. 20, Red Sidewalks reported.
The city's legal case leans partly on federal law. Miami Beach has been a Certified Local Government under the National Historic Preservation Act since 2002, which requires a local review process for historic demolitions. The resolution argues the state law may get in the way of that role, Miami Beach Daily reported.
A second item asks Tallahassee to act
A companion resolution, C7 AP, urges the Legislature to repeal the law or change it to protect buildings in local and national historic districts. It says the law "potentially places hundreds of historic buildings and structures in the City" at risk. Copies would go to South Florida's state lawmakers, Miami-Dade County leaders and neighboring cities.
Neither item lists a cost, a court or the specific legal arguments the city attorney has found. Both list the fiscal impact as not applicable.
How to take part
- Wednesday, Nov. 18, 8:30 a.m.: City Commission meeting, Commission Chamber, City Hall, 1700 Convention Center Drive.
- Both items are on the consent agenda, so they can pass together with other routine items unless a commissioner pulls them for discussion.
- The full Nov. 18 agenda lists both items under consent-agenda resolutions.
More Ocean Drive and South Beach coverage: the Cameo Theater's approval to reopen as a supper club and what Miami Beach voters decided on the Rivani lease.





