The space is the former Segafredo café next to the 1935 Art Deco theater, which Miami New Drama runs for the city. It has about 820 square feet for the restaurant and about 272 square feet for a concession stand and storage, the city manager's memo says.

What's planned

Miami New Drama's proposal lists hours of 11 a.m. to 11 p.m., but the theater told commissioners it plans breakfast, lunch, dinner and after-show service, the Miami Beach Journal reported. Jessica Fuentes of Café Avanti said she wants a livelier, bistro-style spinoff open in the morning and through the day.

Michel Hausmann, Miami New Drama's artistic director, said the theater reached out to Café Avanti. "I want the guarantee that I'm going to have a partner for the next two decades," he said.

Theater leaders said the café shares storage and restrooms with the Colony, and that the old tenant's deliveries sometimes landed in the middle of shows, the Journal reported.

The proposed deal

The memo lays out a five-year lease with two two-year renewals at the city's option. Rent would start at $60,060 a year, about $5,005 a month, and rise 3% a year, or 7% of the café's sales if that is higher. The tenant would also pay about $21,840 in first-year operating costs and a deposit of about $10,010, and would pay for the build-out. These terms can still change in talks.

Why it was close

Three groups bid: Miami New Drama, Sunshine Coffee and Taste Bakery, the memo says. A five-member city panel ranked them in that order, but it was split: the two outside members ranked Sunshine Coffee first, and the three city staff members ranked Miami New Drama first, according to the Journal. Commissioner Joe Magazine said the spot drew too few bids and too little daytime life. "You could have rolled a bowling ball down Lincoln Road," he said of a recent morning visit.

Commissioner David Suarez cast the only no vote. He backed Sunshine Coffee and said "political insiders" shaped the pick, a claim Mayor Steven Meiner and Commissioner Tanya K. Bhatt pushed back on, the Journal reported. Suarez also proposed a two-year trial instead. The item was C2A on the city's Nov. 18 commission agenda.

Read more: new outdoor dining on North Lincoln Lane, the No Vacancy hotel art show and why voters rejected the Rivani lease on Michigan Avenue.

The Art Deco Colony Theatre on Lincoln Road
The 1935 Colony Theatre, run by Miami New Drama. Source